Struggleville Forum
Mig vs Tig - Printable Version

+- Struggleville Forum (https://struggleville.net/forum)
+-- Forum: Shop Talk (https://struggleville.net/forum/forum-12.html)
+--- Forum: Enter The Shop (https://struggleville.net/forum/forum-13.html)
+--- Thread: Mig vs Tig (/thread-96.html)

Pages: 1 2


Mig vs Tig - delpha80 - 05-27-2020

looking at getting a new welder which will be used almost entirely for car restoration type work. Is there a advantage to getting a tig welder or just stick with gas mig with the option to add a spool gun for aluminum?


RE: Mig vs Tig - MiscellaneousDave - 05-27-2020

This thread will be interesting to me as I want to get into welding. Smile


RE: Mig vs Tig - PJ - 05-27-2020

I just have the cheapo wire welder from Harbor Freight. It doesn't have all the bells and whistles of a nice one. I think your only settings are a high/low type switch and a dial to control the wire speed. But I've used it on my exhaust, trunk pan, a roll around shop stool, built a steel work bench with a wood top... welded a cast iron tractor seat to a milk pale.

Just screwing around practicing really. I suck at welding but I can make 2 pieces of metal stick together and the cheap Harbor Freighter hasn't let me down.


RE: Mig vs Tig - MiscellaneousDave - 05-27-2020

(05-27-2020, 03:24 PM)PJ Wrote: I just have the cheapo wire welder from Harbor Freight.  It doesn't have all the bells and whistles of a nice one.  I think your only settings are a high/low type switch and a dial to control the wire speed.  But I've used it on my exhaust, trunk pan, a roll around shop stool, built a steel work bench with a wood top... welded a cast iron tractor seat to a milk pale.

Just screwing around practicing really. I suck at welding but I can make 2 pieces of metal stick together and the cheap Harbor Freighter hasn't let me down.

I am scared to get into welding because I know how I solder and it isn't pretty.  lol


RE: Mig vs Tig - Orion1876 - 05-27-2020

(05-27-2020, 04:36 PM)MiscellaneousDave Wrote:
(05-27-2020, 03:24 PM)PJ Wrote: I just have the cheapo wire welder from Harbor Freight.  It doesn't have all the bells and whistles of a nice one.  I think your only settings are a high/low type switch and a dial to control the wire speed.  But I've used it on my exhaust, trunk pan, a roll around shop stool, built a steel work bench with a wood top... welded a cast iron tractor seat to a milk pale.

Just screwing around practicing really. I suck at welding but I can make 2 pieces of metal stick together and the cheap Harbor Freighter hasn't let me down.

I am scared to get into welding because I know how I solder and it isn't pretty.  lol


I am interested in getting into welding as well.  I would probably go with which ever one is cheaper.  Don't want to spend a ton on it because I am not sure how much I will actually use it.  My soldering was ok last time I soldered something but its been a while, so there is no telling.   Cool


RE: Mig vs Tig - MiscellaneousDave - 05-27-2020

(05-27-2020, 04:49 PM)Orion1876 Wrote:
(05-27-2020, 04:36 PM)MiscellaneousDave Wrote:
(05-27-2020, 03:24 PM)PJ Wrote: I just have the cheapo wire welder from Harbor Freight.  It doesn't have all the bells and whistles of a nice one.  I think your only settings are a high/low type switch and a dial to control the wire speed.  But I've used it on my exhaust, trunk pan, a roll around shop stool, built a steel work bench with a wood top... welded a cast iron tractor seat to a milk pale.

Just screwing around practicing really. I suck at welding but I can make 2 pieces of metal stick together and the cheap Harbor Freighter hasn't let me down.

I am scared to get into welding because I know how I solder and it isn't pretty.  lol


I am interested in getting into welding as well.  I would probably go with which ever one is cheaper.  Don't want to spend a ton on it because I am not sure how much I will actually use it.  My soldering was ok last time I soldered something but its been a while, so there is no telling.   Cool

I wasn't going to go with the stick welding route as I figured it would be better as a beginner to use the electric/gas combo...  Hoping for more input here.

Not to mention I don't have a dedicated circuit handy.  I suppose I could use the dryer plug but would rather not.


RE: Mig vs Tig - PJ - 05-27-2020

(05-27-2020, 08:39 PM)MiscellaneousDave Wrote:
(05-27-2020, 04:49 PM)Orion1876 Wrote:
(05-27-2020, 04:36 PM)MiscellaneousDave Wrote:
(05-27-2020, 03:24 PM)PJ Wrote: I just have the cheapo wire welder from Harbor Freight.  It doesn't have all the bells and whistles of a nice one.  I think your only settings are a high/low type switch and a dial to control the wire speed.  But I've used it on my exhaust, trunk pan, a roll around shop stool, built a steel work bench with a wood top... welded a cast iron tractor seat to a milk pale.

Just screwing around practicing really. I suck at welding but I can make 2 pieces of metal stick together and the cheap Harbor Freighter hasn't let me down.

I am scared to get into welding because I know how I solder and it isn't pretty.  lol


I am interested in getting into welding as well.  I would probably go with which ever one is cheaper.  Don't want to spend a ton on it because I am not sure how much I will actually use it.  My soldering was ok last time I soldered something but its been a while, so there is no telling.   Cool

I wasn't going to go with the stick welding route as I figured it would be better as a beginner to use the electric/gas combo...  Hoping for more input here.

Not to mention I don't have a dedicated circuit handy.  I suppose I could use the dryer plug but would rather not.

I can't imagine an easier set up than the cheapo Harbor Freight one.  Its 110v, you turn it on and hit the trigger.  Smart people grab a mask at some point before hitting the trigger.

Its really a simple machine to use, my welding is just trash.  I always end up pulling away and having too much wire out.


RE: Mig vs Tig - Orion1876 - 05-28-2020

(05-27-2020, 11:23 PM)PJ Wrote:
(05-27-2020, 08:39 PM)MiscellaneousDave Wrote:
(05-27-2020, 04:49 PM)Orion1876 Wrote:
(05-27-2020, 04:36 PM)MiscellaneousDave Wrote:
(05-27-2020, 03:24 PM)PJ Wrote: I just have the cheapo wire welder from Harbor Freight.  It doesn't have all the bells and whistles of a nice one.  I think your only settings are a high/low type switch and a dial to control the wire speed.  But I've used it on my exhaust, trunk pan, a roll around shop stool, built a steel work bench with a wood top... welded a cast iron tractor seat to a milk pale.

Just screwing around practicing really. I suck at welding but I can make 2 pieces of metal stick together and the cheap Harbor Freighter hasn't let me down.

I am scared to get into welding because I know how I solder and it isn't pretty.  lol


I am interested in getting into welding as well.  I would probably go with which ever one is cheaper.  Don't want to spend a ton on it because I am not sure how much I will actually use it.  My soldering was ok last time I soldered something but its been a while, so there is no telling.   Cool

I wasn't going to go with the stick welding route as I figured it would be better as a beginner to use the electric/gas combo...  Hoping for more input here.

Not to mention I don't have a dedicated circuit handy.  I suppose I could use the dryer plug but would rather not.

I can't imagine an easier set up than the cheapo Harbor Freight one.  Its 110v, you turn it on and hit the trigger.  Smart people grab a mask at some point before hitting the trigger.

Its really a simple machine to use, my welding is just trash.  I always end up pulling away and having too much wire out.


That is good to know.   I will have to take a closer look at the welders at Harbor Freight next time I am in store.  I ventured out to Lowes and Home Depot for the first time in quite a while.  Its starting to look more normal around here.


RE: Mig vs Tig - MiscellaneousDave - 05-28-2020

(05-27-2020, 11:23 PM)PJ Wrote:
(05-27-2020, 08:39 PM)MiscellaneousDave Wrote:
(05-27-2020, 04:49 PM)Orion1876 Wrote:
(05-27-2020, 04:36 PM)MiscellaneousDave Wrote:
(05-27-2020, 03:24 PM)PJ Wrote: I just have the cheapo wire welder from Harbor Freight.  It doesn't have all the bells and whistles of a nice one.  I think your only settings are a high/low type switch and a dial to control the wire speed.  But I've used it on my exhaust, trunk pan, a roll around shop stool, built a steel work bench with a wood top... welded a cast iron tractor seat to a milk pale.

Just screwing around practicing really. I suck at welding but I can make 2 pieces of metal stick together and the cheap Harbor Freighter hasn't let me down.

I am scared to get into welding because I know how I solder and it isn't pretty.  lol


I am interested in getting into welding as well.  I would probably go with which ever one is cheaper.  Don't want to spend a ton on it because I am not sure how much I will actually use it.  My soldering was ok last time I soldered something but its been a while, so there is no telling.   Cool

I wasn't going to go with the stick welding route as I figured it would be better as a beginner to use the electric/gas combo...  Hoping for more input here.

Not to mention I don't have a dedicated circuit handy.  I suppose I could use the dryer plug but would rather not.

I can't imagine an easier set up than the cheapo Harbor Freight one.  Its 110v, you turn it on and hit the trigger.  Smart people grab a mask at some point before hitting the trigger.

Its really a simple machine to use, my welding is just trash.  I always end up pulling away and having too much wire out.

Can't you control wire speed?


RE: Mig vs Tig - delpha80 - 05-28-2020

There is a wire feed control knob. But you have to stay in the puddle to keep it from re arching.